When the Body Betrays: Infertility and Body Image
{image credit :: patricio villarroel}
For most of us, the sight of little blue booties or a 20-week ultrasound plastered on facebook is a sweet one. Our hearts are warmed by knowing that a new little life is taking form inside of someone we love. Perhaps it reminds us of those lovely little moments when we were carrying our own child, or it generates excitement for the time in our lives when we’ll be ready to do the same.
But for a smaller, though significant, number, these images send a jab of intense pain through the heart. For women who have been trying to conceive – or who has stopped trying – reminders of the body’s betrayal can be gut-wrenching.
Over seven million women in the United States have spent more than one year trying to conceive, the diagnostic criteria for infertility. This is a little over one in ten women who struggle with what can be one of the most trying and painful experience of a human’s life. And yet, even in the health and body-image world, we usually hear barely a word spoken about how this experience can alter one’s perception of themselves.
In fact, while we do know that infertility is associated with depression, there’s a dearth of research on how infertility impacts individuals’ body image and self-concept. This silence is dangerous because it mirrors the hushed and hidden nature of the issue itself. Couples who are struggling to become pregnant, or faced with their inability to do so, rarely bring this up in the company of others. Ironically perhaps, the color of an infant’s feces becomes appropriate dinner conversation, but detailing your second round of IVF does not.
This type of isolation, whether socially or self-induced, combined with the emotional toll that infertility takes produces all kinds of intense feelings for a woman. She’s faced with working through a form of grief that perhaps few of her loved ones can comprehend. She’s struggling to maintain a relationship with a partner that can be intensely strained by putting intimacy on an egg-timer. And she’s taking a painful assessment of her values in order to make some extremely difficult decisions.
So it’s no surprise that in our society of buck up, cowgirl and sweeping emotions under the proverbial rug, women with infertility turn quickly on themselves, and specifically their bodies.
As women in our culture, we’re simply not used to the fact that sometimes working harder doesn’t produce the outcome that you so desire. We’re taught to believe that if we invest the resources and will into pursuing a goal, we will achieve it. But what about when all of our efforts fail? We feel powerless. We get angry. We get hopeless. And we rage against the bodies that feel as though they are betraying us.
For women with histories of disordered eating, this experience can be especially devastating, and sometimes send them spiraling back into a bitter relationship with food and their bodies. Thoughts of what bodies are “meant” to do swirl through their minds, and the ways in which their own bodies seem to fall short rock their internal world.
And so they do what they know how – they exert control in the only ways they can. Their eating may become restrictive or, conversely, unmanageable, or they may find themselves desperately attempting to bridle their bodies in other ways. They exercise to the point of exhaustion, they chart their basal body temperature with the precision of an air traffic controller, or they analyze every subtle shift in their bodies. And inevitably, as always happens when we attempt to alleviate our anxieties through exerting control on the body, disappointment eventually comes rushing in. And when it does, the pain that is buried and unspoken comes along with it.
Moving this experience out of the shadows is one way to prevent these feelings from narrowing one’s life. This of course comes with a host of other risks – such as feeling exposed and having one’s reproductive organs be, well, out on the table. But carefully selecting individuals one’s trusts to share this experience with can be key to allowing our bodies to release the burden of carrying this on our own.
There are limits to what friends and family can do in terms of support, and so talking to a professional or finding a support group can be helpful in sorting through the myriad of emotions that are triggered as well. For resources and support, check out the Resolve.org page.
Have you ever felt that your body betrayed you? How did you cope with these feelings?
8 Comments
One Trackback
-
[...] tackles the oft-ignored topic of infertility and body image. (Via Medicinal [...]


Joy Tanksley
149 days ago
Thank you so much for writing this piece, Ashley. In my own process of trying to conceive, I had a whole host of body image issues surface. I was thankful to be in a place where I had healed my relationship with food and my body for the most part, and when the old demons came up, I had a set of skills and a wonderful support system for getting through. I can’t imagine what things would have been like had I started this journey several years ago, when things were very dark for me in terms of body image.
I very much relate to what you said about the controlling behaviors emerging – that definitely happened for me, and I was fortunately able to spot it pretty early and ease myself back into a place of trust and peace.
I think the most challenging part for me was going through a very real grief cycle every single month I didn’t conceive. Again, I was thankful to have done so much personal work on accessing and allowing my emotions. Otherwise, I think I would have gone into a depression for sure.
I definitely want to second your advice about “moving the experience out of the shadows.” Sharing my journey with a handful of trusted friends and also working with a mind-body coach helped me feel connected and supported. Even though I conceived in less than a year, so wasn’t diagnosed with infertility, the process was still intense and full of potential for me to either shut down or reach out. This is such an important conversation you have started for any woman who is on the path of trying to conceive, or even just considering it. Thank you!
Marzipan
149 days ago
Ashley, Thank you so much for sharing this post. This is a topic that impacts so many people, and yet is so rarely discussed. LIke joy, I want to second the advice about “moving the experience out of the shadows.” THANK YOU for starting that conversation here today. xoxoxox
Marzipan recently posted..Holiday Cheer, A Confession + A Giveaway
JJ
149 days ago
I haven’t struggled with infertility but had a second trimester miscarriage and found that is another “shadow” experience and one that is also intensely physical. I know I felt intensely violated after the medical intervention necessary… I wonder if that is also an issue with undergoing IVF treatments?
Kimberly Chapman
149 days ago
It’s even more profound when your infertility is specifically linked to diet, and half of the specialists you talk to don’t get that. I have PCOS and finally only succeeded in getting pregnant on a tightly controlled ultra-low-carb diet (which I do not recommend long-term or for otherwise healthy people, it’s horrid, truly). But while my infertility doc in Las Vegas was the one who worked with me on this, when I moved to Austin and we tried for a second child here, the clinic had absolutely no clue about PCOS and diet. As in, they were stumped when I talked to them about PCOS and carb control. Hadn’t occurred to any of the nurses or the doctor I spoke with.
I did the same diet as last time but only ended up with brief chemical pregnancies. So now we’re trying to adopt, in large part so I don’t have to do that maddening cycle of diet, drugs, injections, and humiliations any more. Adoption costs more but if you go through a reputable agency, you’re not gambling with your money the way you are with IVF.
Luckily I long ago stopped caring about body-image issues, accepting that I’m fat and not-hot and that I don’t care, because I’m smart and talented and have better things to be judged by. But yes, I went through all of that body pain. It sucks. Nobody should have to feel that way.
Kimberly Chapman recently posted..Measurements Around The Globe
Lori Lieberman
149 days ago
Thanks, Ashley, for bringing this topic to light. Needless to say, fertility and depression are quite intertwined. I was struck when I read this Biblical text for the first time, through this very lens:
http://dropitandeat.blogspot.com/2011/09/hannahs-story-tale-of-first-reported.html
Lori Lieberman recently posted..This Holiday Of Miracles—Ancient Wisdom About Managing Your Eating
Coley
148 days ago
Thanks for posting this. I spent 5 years trying to conceive and suffering many miscarriages. I and my doctors blamed my overweight body and I ended up losing over 100 pounds…but I still couldn’t remain pregnant. Now after turning to donor eggs I am pregnant..with triplets! I recognised, before I got pregnant, that both my over and undereating were driven by an urge to punish myself for various things (including my inability to sustain a pregnancy). It is a very secret pain, not mentioned often – mostly because people say the stupidest things – the worst being ‘just relax and it will happen’ Can’t express how upsetting that is.
Anyway being pregnant doesn’t remove the memory of that pain and the compassion you feel for those still in the trenches. x
Coley recently posted..16 Weeks
Jessica
148 days ago
Thank you so much for this post!
It took my parents 5 years to get pregnant with me- it was a really hard time for them, but going to an infertility support group helped them immensely. In fact, my mother is still close with women she met in that support group 20+ years later.
“Ironically perhaps, the color of an infant’s feces becomes appropriate dinner conversation, but detailing your second round of IVF does not.” – Such a good point
adele
148 days ago
this paragraph:
“As women in our culture, we’re simply not used to the fact that sometimes working harder doesn’t produce the outcome that you so desire. We’re taught to believe that if we invest the resources and will into pursuing a goal, we will achieve it. But what about when all of our efforts fail? We feel powerless. We get angry. We get hopeless. And we rage against the bodies that feel as though they are betraying us.”
rang so true to me – harder than dealing with knowing i can’t have a baby is knowing that no matter how hard i try, how perfectly i eat, how healthy i am, it will never be enough – why try if we will never get what we want?
it’s a hard thing, and i am glad i am not the only person that feels that pain.